The Coffee & Magic Verdict
Santa Fe is one of the simplest Disney Hotels, but that is also part of its appeal.
You still get the big benefits of staying on-site, including Extra Magic Time, free parking and Disney transport, without paying the prices of the hotels closer to the parks.
The Cars theming gives the rooms plenty of personality, particularly for younger children, although the hotel itself feels much more functional than somewhere like Sequoia Lodge or Newport Bay Club.
For us, it makes most sense when the price difference is significant and you expect to spend the majority of your time in the parks.