The Coffee & Magic Verdict
Disney Newport Bay Club is probably our favourite of the larger Disney hotels. It feels properly like a resort rather than simply somewhere to sleep, with its huge lakeside setting, nautical styling and impressive public areas.
For us, its biggest strength is how well it balances everything. You are close enough to walk comfortably to the parks, there is a genuinely good pool, plenty of places to eat and drink, and the hotel feels noticeably more upmarket than Cheyenne or Santa Fe without reaching Disneyland Hotel prices.
The rooms are pleasant rather than spectacular, but the overall hotel experience makes up for that. We particularly like arriving back here in the evening, when the lake and Disney Village are lit up and the hotel feels a little removed from the busiest parts of the resort.
It is also one of the better Disney hotels for families of five because selected family rooms accommodate an extra person.
If the price difference compared with Sequoia Lodge is reasonable, we would usually choose Newport Bay.